Tankards are awarded for the best individual performances in the league. The Best Match Average Tankard is awarded to the player with the best overall performance in the league. In recent years tankards have also been awarded for the best performances in the individual divisions.
Some of the following details are slightly edited versions of the text that appears on the tankards.
Division 2 Tankard
- 2015–16
- Farr, Peter G (Argumentatives)
- 2014–15
- Hamilton, Michael J (Brighton & Hove 2)
- Brewer, Callum D (Brighton & Hove 2)
- 2013–14
- R JONES (Brighton & Hove 3 & 4)
- 2012–13
- J Graham (Argumentatives)
- 2011–12
- M Costley (Lewes)
- 2009–10
- F Kwiatkowski (St Francis & Haywards Heath)
- 2008–9
- J Herbert (Eastbourne)
- 2007–8
- A Bonnano (East Grinstead)
- 2006–7
- J Graham (Crawley)
- 2005–6
- M Young (Hastings & St Leonards)
- 2004–5
- P G Farr (The Args)
- C Jones (Worthing)
- 2003–4
- R C Noyce (Crawley)
- C Jones (Worthing)
- 2002–3
- P G Farr (The Args)
- 2001–2
- J Sachs (Haywards Heath)
- D Glebocki (The Holt)
- 2000–2001
- D S Hall (Knoll Knights)
- 1999–2000
- L Rhodes (Eastbourne)
- 1998–9
- P Carpenter (Eastbourne)
- 1997–8
- M Finch (Eastbourne)